Return Rate Impact Simulator
Return rate is usually written off as a category constant and never costed. But a return doesn't cost you the refund — and totalled up, it can rival the ad budget.
A return doesn't cost you the refund: it costs two shipping legs, packaging, handling and the share of goods you can't resell. The tool totals that. Starting values are examples only.
What one point of return rate is worth
36.234
Cutting the rate from 14% to 13% is worth this much a year — the same as a 0.45% price rise.
Your current return burden
The numbers you enter stay in your browser and are never sent to a server.
How it's calculated
A return costs four things: both shipping legs (if you pay the return), replacement packaging, handling and inspection, and the largest one, the resale loss.
The resale loss has two parts: the unsellable share is written off at cost, and the sellable share loses the markdown. If opened stock can still sell at full price, this shrinks — which is why packaging design is a returns decision.
It then prices one point of return rate for a year and compares it to an equivalent price rise. That comparison can change decisions: if, on your numbers, a point of returns beats a percent of price, you've found a lever that doesn't cost conversion.
What people most often forget
- Many returns are wrong expectations, not bad products. Size guides, colour accuracy and scale in imagery need no product change and act fastest.
- On a marketplace, returns touch account health. Negative feedback or an A-to-z claim after a bad return counts toward Amazon's order defect rate.
- Measure before removing free returns. The conversion effect varies by category and can cost more than it saves.
- Record return reasons. “Too small” and “arrived damaged” are different problems with different fixes; without the data you can't know where to invest.
- On cross-border returns, shipping a low-value item back can cost more than the item. Local options (a return address, disposal or donation) may be cheaper — but only if planned in advance.
Scope, sources and freshness
A scenario calculator that assumes no category averages: return rate, resellability and markdown are all your inputs. Reputational cost, churn and marketplace metric damage aren't priced here — real, but wider than this tool. Starting values are examples only. Keep every field in one currency.
Sources last reviewed: 14 October 2026
Frequently asked
What does a return really cost?
Not the refund: outbound and return shipping, replacement packaging, handling, and the share that can't be resold. Enter your own numbers and the tool shows the cost per return and total returns cost as a share of revenue.
How do I reduce returns?
In order: sharpen the size guide, align images with real colour and scale, set expectations in the copy, and strengthen packaging. None touch the product and all act fast.
Should I offer free returns?
It depends on the category: it lifts conversion but adds a shipping leg. Measure for two weeks before removing it.
What do I do with a cross-border return?
Shipping a low-value item home can cost more than the item. Common answers: a local return address or 3PL, local disposal or donation for low-value goods, and local outlet resale for mid-value ones.
If your product is ready, let's talk about the rest.
A free 30-minute call about your market, your product and the first 90 days. No pitch — just a clear roadmap.